Dissecting MVC Scaffolded Code for EF Updates

MVC and Entity Framework scaffolding is powerful, but I prefer to know what actually happens before accepting generated code. The code generated to update an entity when an edit has been done looked interesting, so I decided to have a closer look at it.

When an edit is done to an entity, the data is posted as a simple collection of form elements from the web browser. Remember that when working with MVC, we’re closer to the metal than with Web Forms and we are fully exposed to the stateless nature of the web. The gigantic hidden ViewState form field is gone, leaving us in a clean, but stateless world. When the updated data is posted to the server, the server has no more info about it than available in the request. The server doesn’t know where it came from and has to find out itself where, how and what part of it to update.

Tracking Changes

Tracking changes for objects moving across tiers, being disconnected from their original data source is always tricky. I’m still looking for the silver bullet to this problem and one step in the search is to investigate what other have done. In this post, I’ll take a closer look on how the Scaffolded code of MVC handles updates to EF Entities.

Idempotent DB Update Scripts

An idempotent function gives the same result even if it is applied several times. That is exactly how a database update script should behave. It shouldn’t matter if it is run on or multiple times. The result should be the same.

A database update script should be made to first check the state of the database and then apply the changes needed. If the script is done this way, several operations can be combined into one script that works on several databases despite the databases being at different (possibly unknown) state to start with.

For the database schema itself I usually use Visual Studio 2010 database projects that handles updates automatically (in VS2012 the functionality has been changed significantly). Even with the schema updates handled automatically, there are always things that need manual handling. One common case is lookup tables that need initialization.

Null Sematics in LINQ’s Sum

C# LINQ code is not always executed as C# code. With LINQ-to-SQL or Entity Framework it is translated into SQL instead. This can bring unpleasant surprises when things that can’t happen do happen.

One day when you’re deep in the zone coding a marketing specialist shows up with a haunted look because the CEO wants some numbers right now. You know, the CEO wants it NOW as in IMMEDIATELY, within 60 seconds. Well, you’re already kicked out of the zone so let’s fix those numbers. The CEO wants to know the total number of seats in the company’s blue cars (I don’t understand why that’s relevant – but the CEO is the boss so let’s just do it (besides it makes a good example of what I want to show. All right?))

The explanation already took 15 seconds – so now you’re down to 45 seconds to produce the numbers for the CEO. Being a C#/LINQ hacker the fastest tool is of course LINQPad.

5 seconds later (you’re fast at the keyboard!) you’ve got the query done:

Cars.Where(c => c.Color == "Blue").Sum(c => c.Seats)

5 more seconds to compile and run and you’ve got the magic number – 14. The marketing specialist runs off, happy to make it within the required 60 seconds. You get back to coding. The moment when you’ve got into the zone the marketing specialist shows up again (interesting how they always show up exactly when the solution to that hard problem is within reach).

Now the CEO wants the numbers for Green cars as well to tomorrow’s meeting. As it looks like a minor thing, it’s best to do it right away. You switch back to LINQPad and change the color in the Where(...) call and hits F5. This is when everything blows up in your face with an InvalidOperationException.

The null value cannot be assigned to a member with type System.Int32 which is a non-nullable value type.

At least the deadline is more than 60 seconds this time. You’ve got all night to figure out what happened. To save you from a sleepless night, I’ll let you know both what happened and what to do about it.

Database Table Primary Keys

When designing a database, I have a standard of always creating a clustered primary key in each table of type INT IDENTITY(1,1) NOT NULL.

    ID                    INT IDENTITY(1,1)   NOT NULL
    Brand                 NVARCHAR(20)        NOT NULL,
    RegistrationNumber    NVARCHAR(10)        NOT NULL,
    MadeIn                NVARCHAR(20)        NOT NULL

It is simple to create and for 90% of all tables this will give good performance and a small storage footprint. Those 9% of tables that are link tables for many-to-many relationships get a composite primary key, made up of the primary keys from the two related tables. Two simple rules handles 99% of the cases for primary keys. In this post I will go through some considerations for primary keys and show why an INT IDENTITY(1,1) NOT NULL field almost always is a good choice for a clustered primary key. The examples and technical details in this article are written for MS SQL Server, but the concepts should apply to other database engines as well.

Transaction Safety for Manual SQL Updates

When maintaining a system that is in production there are often issues that need to be solved by running custom SQL scripts directly in the production database. There can be different reasons for this:

  • Updating a lookup table to add a new option to dropdown boxes, where there is no user interface for handling the table.
  • Adjusting data in a way not permitted by the normal work flow.
  • Reverting an incorrect operation performed by a user.
Whenever it is time to run SQL directly in the live database I tend to become nervous. One single error and a lot of data could be lost or made incorrect. Usually I make such an update in three steps:

  1. Find the data that should be changed.
  2. Create the update statement and validate it
  3. Run the complete statement.
Software Development is a Job – Coding is a Passion

I'm Anders Abel, an independent systems architect and developer in Stockholm, Sweden.

profile for Anders Abel at Stack Overflow, Q&A for professional and enthusiast programmers

Code for most posts is available on my GitHub account.

Popular Posts



Powered by WordPress with the Passion for Coding theme.